Links
Vexen Crabtree's Live Journal - Church of Satan/Anton LaVey is a Fraud? Satanism is a Nietzsche rip-off?
Sociology, Theology, Anti-Religion and Exploration: Forcing Humanity Forwards
vexen
[info]vexen
Add to Memories
Tell a Friend
Church of Satan/Anton LaVey is a Fraud? Satanism is a Nietzsche rip-off?

Read essay online and leave comment here

Listening To: "Access and amplify" by Icon of Coil

Comments
From: (Anonymous) Date: November 25th, 2003 07:02 am (UTC) (Link)
FUCK YOU!!! Anton Lavey is not a fraud like god.Thy father who is in hell,hollow be thy name. heil SATAN!!! father and lord of the earth, please forgive this man,for he not knows any better. NEMA!!!
From: (Anonymous) Date: May 25th, 2006 09:35 am (UTC) (Link)

Anonymous

FUCK YOU!!! Anton Lavey is not a fraud like god.Thy father who is in hell,hollow be thy name. heil SATAN!!! father and lord of the earth, please forgive this man,for he not knows any better. NEMA!!!


My dear fellow, how have you become like that which we strive to combat?
I am disappointed that the words of a fool have left the mouth of a Satanist.
The text was not an insult to our founder and indeed a great man despite his detractors, it was an answer to a question placed in the context of an insult, if you had actually read it then you would have reacted differently.
I put it to you that you read only what you required to feed your negativity.....
Many thanks for pointing yourself out.

Rev. Danyael Morgan Black
First Church Of The Fallen
www.churchofthefallen.tk
From: (Anonymous) Date: November 26th, 2003 09:19 pm (UTC) (Link)

Muslims

I've read what you said about Muslims, Mohammad and our whole Islamic religion.... I respect your opinion even though I strongly disagree.
Judging a religion with out living through its rituals and reading its bible with at least a good interpretation is not a smart thing to do. Just as you are always asking people not to judge yours.
Just for your information I looked all the points that you mentioned about Mohammad not being sincere and double faced. At the arising of our religion Mohammad and his followers where a minority and would have been stoned if they were public ( and that wouldn’t have been smart ), But let me assure you He never admit that false stone gods where true … Mohammad would have never had any followers if he wasn’t honest or was double standard, remember it’s the second religion on this planet it have to make some sense.
I ask you to read more about Islam and Muslims History and contribution in cases like freeing slaves, maintaining cultural and scientific treasures when others where destroying , killing and burning books.
Again I admire LaVey’s teaching, but don’t agree with all points …. It’s stupid to follow rules blindly …. I wouldn’t kneel when anyone tells me to, at least not blindly.
Sam Abdallah
wamra@yahoo.com

From: (Anonymous) Date: March 17th, 2004 09:57 pm (UTC) (Link)
I am not as such a Satanist myself, being that I find all forms of organized religion an insult to intelligence. But were I forced to choose one for my own purposes it would indeed be Satanism. I am a greater fan of Nietzsche than of Lavey, they are quite similar, that cannot be denied, but in some regards more credit must be given to Lavey for what he actually accomplished and aquired before his death. Lavey died a rich man with much power and fear at his disposal whereas Nietzsche died a madman. Just as Nietzche took up the torch for Schopenhauer, then, in turn, did Lavey for Nietzsche. I turned 20 mere months ago, and I have all such men to thank for my drive to better myself and my position.
docmartian From: [info]docmartian Date: April 28th, 2004 08:15 am (UTC) (Link)

LaVey came up just around the same time as manson....

the nsa got wind of a personality cult in southern california with scary overtones and wanted to make sure that the satanic community was locked down when they heard manson talking about helter-skelter.

helter-skelter is actually what is going to happen when america nukes israel... they're going to run helter-skelter like cockroaches from their radioactiveland and try and cause trouble. but we (america) will put their asses down.

cheers!
Doc
From: (Anonymous) Date: May 16th, 2004 12:46 am (UTC) (Link)

whatever

who cares about this shit?
Get a friggin life for chirst sake.
/me farts and leaves.
From: (Anonymous) Date: October 27th, 2004 09:37 am (UTC) (Link)
Everything about satan is a fraud, even he himself.The only thing that he is good at is misleading and using people.
From: (Anonymous) Date: February 14th, 2005 09:15 pm (UTC) (Link)

YOU CRAZY!! ! !

MAN FACK YOU! ! !How can you say that Satan is a FRAUD ???He uses peoples????REALLY WHAT DO YOU KNOW ABOUT SATANISM IDIOT! ! !?you dident see what others saw and you say he is a Fraud!!!?? I Hope you will Burn for this!!!
From: (Anonymous) Date: December 15th, 2005 09:03 am (UTC) (Link)

Thats not all Satan dose

Satan tells the truth and he makes the weather from vary hot to vary cold to tornados, herracans, flash floods, he dose more then God dose, shit
if you want every thing go throw Satan. as Jesus did not take the earthly kingdoms. he told Satan i will always be a looser a Jackass of lies and nothing more i dont want kingdoms. other hands will tell you Satan Loves you more then God well its true... i pray more to Satan then the jackass of haeven. See Satan loves you more and he just trying get you to follow him. i say follow him. FUCK ALL THE STUPID JACKASSES THATS ON THE RIGHT HAND PATH THERE WORHLESS ASSHOLES JOIN THE LEFT HAND PATH OF LUCIFER
HES NOT SATAN BUT SATANS PARTNER.
From: [info]kat_d9152 Date: March 27th, 2005 08:41 pm (UTC) (Link)

THANK YOU!

I would firstly like to point out that I have read many articles on Satanism online, in books, magazines etc. and I have never before felt compelled to write a 'thank you' note to the authors of said articles, so my praise is rare.
As a practicing Satanist, I have spent months attempting to reconcile, in my head, the supposed charlatan and definite unashamed liar, with the man who brought us excellent 'teachings'. As you may have guessed by now, I am talking about Anton La Vey.
For any Satanists screaming with rage at the fact that I dared call one of our great figureheads an unashamed liar, I wish to emphasise that I am a Satanist, but greater than that, I am an extremely well educated Satanist. I direct all those who think La Vey is unimpeachable to consider his essay on Satanic Weddings in 'Satan Speaks'(page 118) when he states that: "I don't perform Satanic Weddings", following up with the conclusion that the only marriage he would perform would be a demonic one. (one where the bride or groom creates an imaginary ideal partner) Compare this with the photograph in 'The Secret Life of a Satanist' of him actually performing a wedding - pretty conclusive proof, I'd say!
La Vey IS a liar. He admits as much himself, and any who blindly follow his every word without question are no better than the sheepish droves of supernatural optimists who pay through the nose for fortune tellers, unable to see that most (if not all) are simply very efficient cold readers.
Anyway, back to my original point. I desperately did not want him to be a liar, but the more I read, the more he contradicted himself. The information released by his daughter, Zeena was the final stone in my metaphoric coffin. My faith was now being tested, and severely. Could I follow a religion based upon the teachings of self-confessed liar? It was not until I stumbled upon your essay that I found my answer. It really doesn't matter if the source of philosophical truth is pure, or if it was all said in jest, so long as the philosophy itself speaks to people.
Thank you for freeing up my mind for more pressing issues.

live_on_hate From: [info]live_on_hate Date: March 31st, 2005 04:25 am (UTC) (Link)

Learning

I just got bought LaVeys book offline today. I also read Brian Warners auto-bio. I hope by reading LaVeys book I am not tempted to become as ignorant and arrogant as some who have posted comments on here. Live life only as you wish, trample the weak, and hurdle the dead.
From: (Anonymous) Date: April 27th, 2005 11:57 pm (UTC) (Link)

Lavey a fraud...

I've been very confused myself. I seem to be finding info from unbiased and biased sources that confirm that Lavey lied about most of his legend.
I have a strong distaste for Confabulators, I've dealt with alot of them and they piss me right the fuck off.
I questioon the integrity of a man that would set up a great irreligion like Satanism and yet lie so much and confabulate great stories about onself to make onself out to be bigger/greater than one is. In psychological terms, does'nt a person whom confabulates alot to boost ones own ego by getting the adoration of mindless sheep do so for a lack of something in their own psyche and personal self-esteem; If one is so strong, why would they feel a need to make up fantastic stories about themselves to get respect from people???
I question Laveys integrity as a person{I'm somewhat undecided however}, I depise those that confabulate; nonetheless, like you said Vexen, it does'nt affect the usefullness and validity of his philosophy, I still admire it.
Lavey the philosopher, a intriquing and intelligent person; Lavey-the person whom confabulated, not someone I can really respect on the personal level.
I've never felt the need to confabulate myself in order to look big; I am what I am, I've found blatantly honesty to be best and most useful, my ego is strong enough to not care what others think so that I would confabulate to get their respect.
However, I will say this for Lavey, at leats his lies did'nt hurt anyonem they were lies to make himself look big, but they did not have a direct hurtful affect on anyones physical well beeing or really even their mental well-beeing{so long as Satanists learn to seperate Lavey the Satanic philosopher from Lavey the confabulating man}.
But again, for someone whom talked so much of beeing comfortable in ones own ego beeing satanic, I wonder-why did he feel the need to pump himself up on lies to make himself look greater than he was???

I think the CoS needs to take more "RESPONSIBILITY" in informing people whom wish to join them, or those whom would call themselves Satanists, and people in general about such things; Lavey himself should've showed more "responsibility" in this too; How can they talk of "responsibility to the repsonisble" so much when they he confabulated and they don't go out of their way to inform people and go out of their way to make excuses for his actions?

Again, I still respect Laveys philosophy and the stuff he came up with and wrote,etc, philosophically and for bringing Satanism out of the gutters and into a respected limelight, but his lies can only hurt his church and his own person.

Bill "Iconoclastithon" Baker
vexen From: [info]vexen Date: April 28th, 2005 06:02 pm (UTC) (Link)

Re: Lavey a fraud...

"As a Satanist, I use LaVey's works as I use any other material or source. For my own gains and self empowerment. I do not see that it is important whether LaVey was honest, truthful, a nice person or even rich. I don't care if he was sincere or not... we can still use his writings. LaVey has created something that is useful to me even if it was all for himself. We should not doubt for one moment that everything he done was for himself. I wouldn't believe him if he said otherwise!"

This comes from my page http://www.dpjs.co.uk/counter/fraud.html , which this very discussion board is based on.

Why do you care so much about whether a dead guy bigged himself up or not? Seriously... are you writing a new biography? Are you trying to say something that hasn't been said before or trying to tell people something new, as if they haven't already looked into it themselves? What are your motives, and what do you want to achieve?

How can you, after reading the page linked, STILL think that anyone thinks LaVey was some goody-goody who never lied? Are you naive? Satanists are the least naive people I know - they KNOW that LaVey lied, because LaVey was a human! Everyone lies. But, the Church of Satan exists, it's philosophies are sound and it's outlook on life is meaningful and empowering. So whatever LaVey's motives were, whatever his tactics, they WORKED. THAT is the seperation of the man from the work. It's time to drop the past, buddy, and direct your energies to the future!
From: (Anonymous) Date: May 7th, 2005 10:08 am (UTC) (Link)

Undying love..........

I have not heard of Nietzsche. I have heard that it is $25 to get a card saying that you are a member of the Satanic Church ( is this true?). I was willing to pay that a few years ago, When I used to love reading he's work I had almost all his books other then "The Secret life of a Satanist." I even did a report on his writings in my high school! I still lust for him like a high school girl!
From: (Anonymous)